Tax-Loss Harvesting Gets an Upgrade: What Investors Need to Know

What do you get the wealthy client who has everything? The answer, according to savvy money managers, might surprise you: a loss-making investment.

This seemingly counterintuitive strategy is the basis for Wall Street’s latest tax-saving innovation—tax-aware long-short strategies. These approaches are gaining traction among the ultra-wealthy, combining hedge fund tactics with personalized portfolio management to unlock a level of tax efficiency rarely seen with traditional tax planning methods.

While tax-loss harvesting, a long-standing wealth management technique, is familiar territory for many investors, this fresh spin ensures losses to offset gains in almost any market condition. With record-high equity prices and the rise of new AI millionaires facing significant tax bills, this strategy is exploding in popularity. At AQR Capital Management, a pioneer in the field, assets in tax long-short strategies surged to $9.9 billion by late 2024—a nearly twofold increase in just six months, Bloomberg reports.

What Is Tax-Loss Harvesting?

Tax-loss harvesting has long been a favorite strategy of high-net-worth individuals. It involves selling investments that have lost value to offset taxes owed on gains from other, more successful investments. However, conventional tax-loss harvesting has a significant drawback: it relies on the availability of losses, which can be scarce during long market rallies.

That’s where the tax-aware long-short strategy comes in. This advanced approach leverages personalized investment accounts to strategically bet on certain stocks while shorting others, practically guaranteeing a mix of gains and losses. The losses can then be harvested for tax benefits without sacrificing overall portfolio growth.

"It's about maximizing after-tax returns," explains David Kabiller, co-founder of AQR Capital Management. "Tax efficiency has become a critical component of wealth preservation for our clients."

Tax-loss harvesting has long been a key strategy for minimizing tax burdens, but the rise of tax-aware long-short strategies are a decided upgrade for high-net-worth taxpayers. These strategies allow investors to generate losses in certain positions while still pursuing overall portfolio growth.

As Andrew Altfest, President of Altfest Personal Wealth Management, told WealthManagement.com, "Tax-loss harvesting is a key strategy for managing client portfolios efficiently, helping to minimize tax liability while maintaining long-term investment goals."

Why Is This Controversial?

Critics argue that these strategies highlight systemic inequalities in the tax system. Because the U.S. tax code allows investors to defer taxes on unrealized gains until an asset is sold, the ultra-rich can use complex structures like tax-aware long-short portfolios to minimize their tax burden indefinitely. According to opponents, tax harvesting is legal, but the disparity in who benefits from these strategies exacerbates wealth inequality.

While the Biden administration has proposed taxing unrealized gains to address such disparities, these measures face significant political and practical hurdles. For now, the wealthiest investors continue to benefit from the flexibility of tax-loss harvesting.

The Growing Accessibility of Tax Harvesting

While advanced strategies like tax-aware long-short portfolios remain exclusive to the ultra-wealthy, tools like Tax Alpha are bridging the gap for everyday investors.

Tax Alpha, a software solution used by financial advisors and individual investors, automates the process of identifying tax-saving opportunities. The platform scans portfolios, flags underperforming assets, and suggests sales to offset gains, making tax-efficient investing more accessible to the general public.

"With tools like Tax Alpha, we're democratizing access to strategies that were once the domain of elite wealth managers," says Karen Mitchell, a tax strategy consultant. "It’s not a perfect substitute for long-short strategies, but it helps everyday investors keep more of their money."

A Look to the Future

As tax laws evolve and scrutiny on wealth inequality increases, the future of tax-aware strategies remains uncertain. The IRS and other global regulators are already eyeing ways to tighten oversight. Proposed changes include stricter reporting requirements and caps on tax deferrals for high-net-worth individuals.

Still, demand for tax-efficient investing shows no signs of slowing. For the ultra-rich, tax-loss harvesting remains not just a tool but a cornerstone of financial strategy. In short, tax planning is the last great frontier of wealth management. Those who master it will continue to reap outsized rewards.

Tax-Loss Harvesting Gets an Upgrade: What Investors Need to Know

Want tax & accounting tips and insights?